Posted by Lydia Schultz on Thursday, June 21, 2012
“Soldier Bear” is an
entertaining but curious amalgam of fiction and history.Set mostly during World War 2, “Soldier Bear”
follows a group of Polish soldiers, displaced by the Nazi invasion of their
homeland, and their animal mascot, Voytek the bear.
This book is billed as
fiction, but draws on an actual historical event.The author includes photos of Voytek and some
of human and animal friends.As an
adult, the choice to call this fiction made me wonder—how much is true?What exactly caused it to be labeled fiction?
I suspect, though, that a typical student reader would have few of these qualms.The book provides some good insights into
what life is like for soldiers in general and for these soldiers in this era in
particular.The story is highly
engaging—Voytek is quite a lively character, and his Polish friends are clearly
devoted to him.Voytek becomes an
important symbol to the men—he is made an official Polish soldier, and his
image is embossed on their troop badge.
I
do wonder what sort of children would be drawn to this book.I’m not sure that it would have the broad
appeal of most “animal” books.Because
Voytek is taught to drink beer and eat lighted cigarettes, I can hear the
animal lovers reacting with outrage.More likely readers would be students who are interested in reading
about soldiers and war.Such readers
would learn about both the boredom and the brutality of war.
I am a school librarian and part-time college English teacher. I hope to review many of the books I read, both in the context of my research about children's books as well as in my pursuit of recreational reading. I want to share what I read--so what else is new?
Please feel free to contact me. I welcome hearing feedback and advice. If you would like to comment on a particular post, click on the title of the post and a comment box will appear after the post when the page reloads.